Hollow Body V Solid Body Electric Guitars

For those unfamiliar, the primary difference between hollow and solid-body electric guitars is the construction method used in the manufacturing process. For example, hollow-body guitars are constructed with a carved or laminated top and back, often with f-shaped sound holes, similar to those on violins. The sides are bent into shape and then attached to the top and back, creating a resonant chamber. Solid-body guitars, as the name suggests, are carved from a single, solid piece of wood (or several pieces glued together), eliminating the resonant chamber seen in hollow-body designs.

In the following article, we’re going to explore the difference between these two construction methods and how each influences tone and playability and handles feedback. We’ll also list some of the pros and cons that might which construction method is best suited to you. So if you have been considering a hollow body guitar over a solid body or vice versa you should find the information presented below interesting.

A Quick Word On Tone and Playability
One of the most fascinating aspects of playing guitar is the range of options available that have a distinct influence on playability and tone. For example, when discussing acoustic guitars, the choice of soundboard material (top of the guitar) has a major influence on how the guitar sounds, and responds to being played, amongst a myriad of other factors. When it comes to electric guitars, everything from the pickups to the choice of wood used in the construction of the guitar shapes the guitarist's experience with the instrument. So, while there are very real differences that can be attributed to the construction method, keep in mind this is just part of a much larger sonic landscape, as just about everything on a guitar plays a role in how the guitar sounds and plays.

Tonal Differences between Solid and Hollow-Body Guitars

The earliest electric guitars, developed in the 1930s, were essentially hollow or semi-hollow body archtop guitars (characterized by their curved, or “arched,” top and back). These were made in response to the need for guitarists to be heard over louder orchestras in big band and jazz settings.

The solid-body electric guitar, as we recognize it today, emerged ten years later, becoming popularized in the 1950s, with the likes of Leo Fender and Les Paul playing significant roles in its development. The solid body design addressed issues like feedback that were common with hollow body electrics, especially at higher volumes.

The absence of a resonating chamber means solid-body guitars produce sound primarily through the vibration of the strings and the resonance of the solid wood body. The tonal output is direct with pronounced high frequencies and tight low-end response. As a result, solid-body guitars are highly regarded for their clarity, sustain, and precision.

On the other hand, hollow and semi-hollow body guitars possess internal cavities that shape and color the sound, much like an acoustic guitar, giving them a unique tonal richness. Hollow body guitars, with their completely open cavities, offer warm, deep, and resonant tones, making them popular in jazz and blues. Their resonating air chambers emphasize midrange frequencies. Semi-hollow designs, which feature a solid block of wood running through the center of the body, strike a balance between the warmth and resonance of a hollow body and the clarity and sustain of a solid body making them well-suited for genres like rockabilly, jazz, and even some forms of rock.

How Solid-Body and Hollow-Body Construction Influences Sustain

In simple terms, sustain refers to how long the vibrations of a string, once struck or plucked, can resonate and continue to produce sound. Sustain is directly influenced by how the vibrations from the guitar strings travel through the guitar’s body.

As solid-body guitars are made of a single, dense piece of wood, they lack the internal air spaces that would otherwise absorb some of the energy of the string vibrations. As a result, the energy remains primarily within the string and the solid structure of the guitar, allowing for prolonged vibration and, therefore, longer sustain.

In the case of hollow-body guitars, the internal air chambers play a significant role. When strings vibrate, some of that energy moves the air within the hollow spaces, causing the sound to resonate differently. However, this air movement also absorbs some of the string’s energy, shortening the duration of the note’s sustain.

As discussed above, semi-hollow body guitars combine characteristics from both solid and hollow-body designs. So, while a semi-hollow body might deliver longer sustain than a fully hollow guitar, it usually won’t possess the same amount of sustain as a solid body guitar.

This isn’t to say sustain, or a lack thereof is necessarily a bad thing. As we’ll discuss further along the importance of sustain is usually genre specific.

How Solid-Body and Hollow-Body Guitars Handle Feedback

Feedback refers to the looped sound that occurs when a guitar’s amplified sound resonates within the guitar’s body, producing a sustained, often high-pitched ringing or howling noise that can escalate in volume and intensity. This can be caused when the guitar is too close to the amplifier or when the volume and gain levels are high.

As explained at the very beginning of this article, solid-body guitars were designed primarily to reduce unwanted feedback. The solid construction minimizes the amount of external vibrations that can cause the strings to resonate sympathetically, leading to feedback. As a result, they can handle higher volumes and gain settings without being prone to feedback.

On the other hand, hollow and semi-hollow body guitars have cavities within the guitar’s body, which can amplify external sounds and result in feedback far more readily. This is especially the case with fully hollow body guitars, where the entire inner chamber can act like an acoustic chamber, resonating with external sounds.

Semi-hollow body guitars with their center block of wood, help to reduce some of this feedback, bridging the gap between the resistance of a solid body and the susceptibility of a hollow body. Keep in mind however, that while feedback can be a challenge, many players over the years have harnessed it creatively, including Jimi Hendrix, Pete Townshend of the Who, and Neil Young to name just a few.

Solid-Body and Hollow-Body Guitars in Musical Genres

So, as we have established above. Solid-body guitars, due to their dense construction, offer a tonal clarity that makes them well-suited for genres requiring high levels of distortion and sustain, such as rock, metal, and punk. The solid construction means they have a reduced natural resonance compared to their hollow counterparts, but this also means they can withstand high volumes and gain settings with minimal feedback. The tonal characteristics of solid body guitars, combined with their ability to resist feedback, allow for a wide dynamic range and precise articulation. As such, they’re not just limited to rock and metal; they’re also common in pop, country, and many other styles where a clear and direct sound is desired. In simple terms, solid-body guitars are common in almost all musical genres.

Hollow and semi-hollow body guitars have a warmer, more resonant tone due to the air cavities within their bodies. In a genre such as jazz, they are ideally suited as jazz guitarists frequently employ fast, intricate phrases and solos, which don’t necessarily benefit from extended note durations aka sustain. Quick, staccato notes can articulate complex melodic ideas with clarity, ensuring each note in a rapid sequence is distinguishable.

Semi-hollow guitars maintain some of the warm resonance of a hollow body but with a center block of wood that increases sustain and helps combat feedback. This makes semi-hollow guitars versatile, and suitable for genres like jazz, blues, rock, and even some forms of pop and indie music.

Factors for Guitarists to Consider

Stuck between making a decision between a solid-body and hollow-body guitar? Consider the points listed below.

1. Feedback Susceptibility:
   • Hollow Body: Most susceptible to feedback.
   • Semi-Hollow: Moderately susceptible, less than hollow bodies but more than solid bodies.
   • Solid Body: Least susceptible to feedback.
2. Weight and Comfort:
   • Hollow Body: Generally lighter, which can be more comfortable for extended playing.
   • Semi-Hollow: A middle ground in terms of weight, offering a balance between hollow and solid bodies.
   • Solid Body: Typically heavier, which can affect playing comfort during longer sessions.
3. Tonal Characteristics:
   • Hollow Body: Warm and round tone.
   • Semi-Hollow: Blend of warmth from hollow bodies and clarity of solid bodies.
   • Solid Body: Clear, direct, and often brighter tone.
4. Maintenance and Modification:
   • Hollow Body: Hardest to work on due to internal construction. In many cases, if changing pickups for example, hollow-body guitars usually do not feature cavities so all work has to be undertaken through the f-holes, making modifications more time-consuming and potentially more expensive.
   • Semi-Hollow: Easier than hollow bodies but still more challenging than solid bodies, especially if there’s limited access to the inside.
   • Solid Body: Easiest to modify or repair. Pickups can be changed with relative ease, and electronics are typically easily accessible.
5. Durability and Touring:
   • Hollow Body: More fragile due to their construction, requiring extra care during transportation.
   • Semi-Hollow: More robust than hollow bodies but still necessitates care.
   • Solid Body: Most durable and can generally withstand the rigors of touring and regular gigging.
6. Playing Context:
   • Hollow Body: Often favored for jazz, blues, and some older rock styles.
   • Semi-Hollow: Versatile and can be used across jazz, blues, rock, and more.
   • Solid Body: Broadly used across many genres, especially where higher volumes and distortion are prevalent.

Final Thoughts

I personally own and play both solid-body and hollow-body guitars. Both have their places, meaning I don’t necessarily have a strong preference either way. However, I have found that the choice between the two often comes down to context or a “right tools for the job” approach.

For example, if you play hard rock or metal a hollow-body guitar will be less reliable with regard to feedback, and prevent you from playing with excessive amounts of gain. Alternatively, if you play covers, versatility will be an important consideration making a solid-body electric guitar, often a better choice.

If you are a touring musician the fragility of a hollow-body guitar, with respect to transporting the guitar should also be considered, however, this may need to be balanced against the lighter weight of a hollow-body guitar being more comfortable to play over long periods. Also keep in mind, especially if you like to tinker with your guitars, hollow and semi-hollow body guitars are typically harder to work on. Changing pickups or electronics e.g. potentiometers on a solid body guitar is a relatively simple task, however, on a hollow body guitar, you will often need to work through the F-holes using tricks such as lowering the components into the body of the guitar using fishing line. Of course, tonality is the most important consideration for the majority of guitarists, and the warmth of a hollow-body guitar may be a better for for you.

If you are undecided, clearly the best option is to have both 🙂 but if it comes down to one or the other and you are new to guitar or are unsure of the direction your playing is likely to go in, a solid body guitar will be the safer option, at least until you have a better idea of kind of music you want to play.

FAQ